| All-CHA Teams | |
| | | | | | | | |
| |
1999-00 |
| First Team | Second Team | |
| G | Greg Gardner, Niagara | Steve Briere, Alabama-Huntsville | |
| D | Chris MacKenzie, Niagara | Shane Stewart, Alabama-Huntsville | |
| D | Stefan Bjork, Bemidji State | Brant Somerville, Findlay | |
| F | Kyle Martin, Niagara | Mikko Sivonen, Niagara | |
| F | Mike Isherwood, Niagara | Calvin Chartrand, Bemidji State | |
| F | Nathan Bowen, Alabama-Huntsville | Brian Gornick, Air Force | |
| |
| |
2000-01 |
| First Team | Second Team | |
| G | Marc Kielkucki, Air Force | Kevin Fines, Findlay | |
| D | Brant Somerville, Findlay | Clay Simmons, Bemidji State | |
| D | Darren Curry, Alabama-Huntsville | Tyler Kindle, Wayne State | |
| F | Brian Gornick, Air Force | Karlis Zirnis, Alabama-Huntsville | |
| F | Dwayne Blais, Alabama-Huntsville | Bernie Sigrist, Niagara | |
| F | Jason Durbin, Wayne State | Andy Berg, Air Force | |
| |
| |
2001-02 |
| First Team | Second Team | |
| G | David Guerrera, Wayne State | Grady Hunt, Bemidji State | |
| D | Tyler Kindle, Wayne State | Scott Crawford, Niagara | |
| D | Tyler Butler, Alabama-Huntsville | Brant Somerville, Findlay | |
| F | Jason Durbin, Wayne State | Chris Vail, Wayne State | |
| F | Marty Goulet, Bemidji State | Riley Riddell, Bemidji State | |
| F | Derek Olson, Air Force | Rigel Shaw, Findlay | |
| F | | Steve Charlebois, Alabama-Huntsville | |
| |
| |
2002-03 |
| First Team | Second Team | |
| G | Grady Hunt, Bemidji State | Scott Munroe, Alabama-Huntsville | |
| D | Ryan Leasa, Alabama-Huntsville | Tyler Butler, Alabama-Huntsville | |
| D | Bryce Methven, Bemidji State | Keith Stanich, Wayne State | |
| F | Joe Tallari, Niagara | Steve Charlebois, Alabama-Huntsville | |
| F | Marty Goulet, Bemidji State | Andy Berg, Air Force | |
| F | Jared Ross, Alabama-Huntsville | Barret Ehgoetz, Niagara | |
| |
| |
2003-04 |
| First Team | Second Team | |
| G | Jeff Van Nynatten, Niagara | Grady Hunt, Bemidji State | |
| D | Jeremy Schreiber, Alabama-Huntsville | Andrew Lackner, Niagara | |
| D | Bryce Methven, Bemidji State | Peter Jonsson, Bemidji State | |
| F | Jared Ross, Alabama-Huntsville | Kris Wiebe, Findlay | |
| F | Barret Ehgoetz, Niagara | Joe Tallari, Niagara | |
| F | Brendan Cook, Bemidji State | Riley Riddell, Bemidji State | |
| |
| |
2004-05 |
| First Team | Second Team | |
| G | Scott Munroe, Alabama-Huntsville | Matt Kelly, Wayne State | |
| D | Peter Jonsson, Bemidji State | Brian Gineo, Air Force | |
| D | Jeremy Schreiber, Alabama-Huntsville | Jeff Winchester, Alabama-Huntsville | |
| F | Andrew Murray, Bemidji State | Bruce Mulherin, Alabama-Huntsville | |
| F | Jared Ross, Alabama-Huntsville | Brendan Cook, Bemidji State | |
| F | Barret Ehgoetz, Niagara | Ryan Gale, Niagara | |
| |
| |
2005-06 |
| First Team | Second Team | |
| G | Scott Munroe, Alabama-Huntsville | Jeff Van Nynatten, Niagara | |
| D | Andrew Martens, Bemidji State | Steve Kovalchik, Wayne State | |
| D | Jeremy Schreiber, Alabama-Huntsville | Michael Mayra, Air Force | |
| F | Sean Bentivoglio, Niagara | Ted Cook, Niagara | |
| F | Luke Erickson, Bemidji State | Eric Ehn, Air Force | |
| F | Bruce Mulherin, Alabama-Huntsville | Les Reaney, Niagara | |
| |
| |
2006-07 |
| First Team | Second Team | |
| G | Matt Climie, Bemidji State | Juliano Pagliero, Niagara | |
| D | Shaun Arvai, Alabama-Huntsville | Dan Iliakis, Wayne State | |
| D | Pat Oliveto, Niagara | Mike Salekin, Alabama-Huntsville | |
| F | Sean Bentivoglio, Niagara | Aaron Clarke, Robert Morris | |
| F | Ted Cook, Niagara | Grant Selinger, Alabama-Huntsville | |
| F | Travis Winter, Bemidji State | Les Reaney, Niagara | |
| |
| |
2007-08 |
| First Team | Second Team | |
| G | Juliano Pagliero, Niagara | Matt Climie, Bemidji State | |
| D | Jeff Caister, Wayne State | Tyler Gotto, Niagara | |
| D | Cody Bostock, Bemidji State | | |
| D | Ryan Annesley, Niagara | | |
| F | Ryan Cruthers, Robert Morris | Matt Caruana, Niagara | |
| F | Vince Rocco, Niagara | Travis Winter, Bemidji State | |
| F | Stavros Paskaris, Wayne State | Chris Margott, Robert Morris | |
| |
| |
2008-09 |
| First Team | Second Team | |
| G | Juliano Pagliero, Niagara | Matt Dalton, Bemidji State | |
| D | Denny Urban, Robert Morris | Tyler Gotto, Niagara | |
| D | Brad Hunt, Bemidji State | Cody Bostock, Bemidji State | |
| F | Matt Read, Bemidji State | Tyler Scofield, Bemidji State | |
| F | Chris Margott, Robert Morris | Vince Rocco, Niagara | |
| F | Nathan Longpre, Robert Morris | Egor Mironov, Niagara | |
| |
| |
2009-10 |
| First Team | Second Team | |
| G | Dan Bakala, Bemidji State | Cameron Talbot, Alabama-Huntsville | |
| D | Denny Urban, Robert Morris | Dave Cowan, Robert Morris | |
| D | Brad Hunt, Bemidji State | Tyler Gotto, Niagara | |
| F | Matt Read, Bemidji State | Chris Kushneriuk, Robert Morris | |
| F | Chris Moran, Niagara | Ian Lowe, Bemidji State | |
| F | Nathan Longpre, Robert Morris | Ryan Olidis, Niagara | |
| |
| |
