| Atlantic Hockey All-Rookie Teams | |
| | | | | | | | |
| |
2003-04 |
| G | Scott Tomes, Connecticut | | |
| D | Reid Cashman, Quinnipiac | | |
| D | Jamie Hunt, Mercyhurst | | |
| F | Pierre-Luc O'Brien, Sacred Heart | | |
| F | Matt Scherer, Connecticut | | |
| F | James Sixsmith, Holy Cross | | |
| |
| |
2004-05 |
| G | Brad Smith, Connecticut | | |
| D | Matt Sorteberg, Quinnipiac | | |
| D | Scott Marchesi, Sacred Heart | | |
| F | Ben Cottreau, Mercyhurst | | |
| F | Ben Nelson, Quinnipiac | | |
| F | Alexandre Parent, Sacred Heart | | |
| |
| |
2005-06 |
| G | Dan Giffin, Canisius | | |
| D | Sean Erickson, Connecticut | | |
| D | Tim Manthey, Army | | |
| F | Bear Trapp, Sacred Heart | | |
| F | Anthony Canzoneri, Bentley | | |
| F | Jeff Gumear, Bentley | | |
| F | Chris Trafford, Mercyhurst | | |
| |
| |
2006-07 |
| G | Louis Menard, RIT | | |
| D | Cullen Eddy, Mercyhurst | | |
| D | Al Mazur, RIT | | |
| F | Anton Kharin, RIT | | |
| F | Josh Heidinger, Canisius | | |
| F | Owen Meyer, Army | | |
| |
| |
2007-08 |
| G | Joe Calvi, Bentley | | |
| D | Jeff Terminesi, Mercyhurst | | |
| D | Mark Znutas, Holy Cross | | |
| F | Everett Sheen, Holy Cross | | |
| F | Vincent Scarsella, Canisius | | |
| F | Erik Peterson, Bentley | | |
| |
| |
2008-09 |
| G | Kyle Rank, Bentley | | |
| D | Marcel Alvarez, Army | | |
| D | Scott Mathis, Air Force | | |
| F | David Kostuch, Canisius | | |
| F | Phil Ginand, Mercyhurst | | |
| F | Tyler Brenner, RIT | | |
| |
| |
2009-10 |
| G | Steven Legato, Sacred Heart | | |
| D | Alex Greke, Connecticut | | |
| D | Chris Tanev, RIT | | |
| F | Joe Campanelli, Bentley | | |
| F | Eric Delong, Sacred Heart | | |
| F | Adam Pleskach, American International | | |
| |
| |
