| All-Atlantic Hockey Teams | |
| | | | | | | | |
| |
2003-04 |
| First Team | Second Team | |
| G | Jamie Holden, Quinnipiac | Tony Quesada, Holy Cross | | |
| D | T.J. Kemp, Mercyhurst | Reid Cashman, Quinnipiac | | |
| D | Eric Nelson, Connecticut | Konn Hawkes, Sacred Heart | | |
| F | Jeff Dams, Holy Cross | Garrett Larson, Sacred Heart | | |
| F | Tim Olsen, Connecticut | Mike Carter, Mercyhurst | | |
| F | Guillaume Caron, American International | David Wrigley, Mercyhurst | | |
| |
| |
2004-05 |
| First Team | Second Team | |
| G | Frank Novello, American International | Jamie Holden, Quinnipiac | | |
| G | Bryan Worosz, Canisius | | | |
| D | Reid Cashman, Quinnipiac | Conrad Martin, Mercyhurst | | |
| D | T.J. Kemp, Mercyhurst | Kalen Wright, Sacred Heart | | |
| F | Tyler McGregor, Holy Cross | Matt Craig, Quinnipiac | | |
| F | Pierre-Luc O'Brien, Sacred Heart | Pierre Napert-Frenette, Holy Cross | | |
| F | Tim Olsen, Connecticut | David Wrigley, Mercyhurst | | |
| |
| |
2005-06 |
| First Team | Second Team | |
| G | Jason Smith, Sacred Heart | Brad Roberts, Army | | |
| G | | Tony Quesada, Holy Cross | | |
| D | Jamie Hunt, Mercyhurst | Josh Chase, Bentley | | |
| D | Jon Landry, Holy Cross | Tim Manthey, Army | | |
| F | Tyler McGregor, Holy Cross | Pierre Napert-Frenette, Holy Cross | | |
| F | Dave Borrelli, Mercyhurst | Ben Cottreau, Mercyhurst | | |
| F | Pierre-Luc O'Brien, Sacred Heart | Alexandre Parent, Sacred Heart | | |
| |
| |
2006-07 |
| First Team | Second Team | Third Team | |
| G | Jason Smith, Sacred Heart | Josh Kassel, Army | Louis Menard, RIT | |
| D | Jon Landry, Holy Cross | Tim Manthey, Army | Sean Erickson, Connecticut | |
| D | Scott Marchesi, Sacred Heart | Brent Patry, RIT | Al Mazur, RIT | |
| F | Eric Ehn, Air Force | Simon Lambert, RIT | Luke Flicek, Army | |
| F | Pierre-Luc O'Brien, Sacred Heart | Andrew Ramsey, Air Force | Jeff Gumaer, Bentley | |
| F | James Sixsmith, Holy Cross | Matt Scherer, Connecticut | Jereme Tendler, American International | |
| |
| |
2007-08 |
| First Team | Second Team | Third Team | |
| G | Josh Kassel, Army | Beau Erickson, Connecticut | Joe Calvi, Bentley | |
| D | Zach McKelvie, Army | Scott Marchesi, Sacred Heart | Bobby Raymond, RIT | |
| D | Dan Ringwald, RIT | Greg Flynn, Air Force | Matt Burke, Holy Cross | |
| F | Simon Lambert, RIT | Owen Meyer, Army | Eric Ehn, Air Force | |
| F | Alexandre Parent, Sacred Heart | Ben Cottreau, Mercyhurst | Brodie Sheahan, Holy Cross | |
| F | Luke Flicek, Army | Bear Trapp, Sacred Heart | Jereme Tendler, American International | |
| |
| |
2008-09 |
| First Team | Second Team | Third Team | |
| G | Andrew Volkening, Air Force | Ryan Zapolski, Mercyhurst | Kyle Rank, Bentley | |
| D | Greg Flynn, Air Force | Bobby Raymond, RIT | Alan Mazur, RIT | |
| D | Zach McKelvie, Army | Sean Erickson, Connecticut | Carl Hudson, Canisius | |
| D | Dan Ringwald, RIT | | | |
| F | Jacques Lamoureux, Air Force | Dain Prewitt, Bentley | Matt Fairchild, Air Force | |
| F | Owen Meyer, Army | Steve Cameron, Mercyhurst | Jason Weeks, Canisius | |
| F | Brennan Sarazin, RIT | Matt Pierce, Mercyhurst | Scott Pitt, Mercyhurst | |
| |
| |
2009-10 |
| First Team | Second Team | Third Team | |
| G | Jared DeMichiel, RIT | Andrew Volkening, Air Force | Ryan Zapolski, Mercyhurst | |
| D | Tim Kirby, Air Force | Marcel Alvarez, Army | Paul Ferraro, Sacred Heart | |
| D | Dan Ringwald, RIT | Carl Hudson, Canisius | Chris Tanev, RIT | |
| F | Cory Conacher, Canisius | Brandon Coccimigilo, Mercyhurst | Cameron Burt, RIT | |
| F | Nick Johnson, Sacred Heart | Andrew Favot, RIT | Dave Jarman, Sacred Heart | |
| F | Jacques Lamoureux, Air Force | Cody Omilusik, Army | Vincent Scarcella, Canisius | |
| |
| |
